Intellectual Schelling Points

  • Observations — Researchers can agree that observations have occurred, or allegedly have occurred, without agreeing on the true interpretation of those observations. Those observations, or alleged observations, can then form the basis for successful intellectual exchange.
  • Methods — Researchers can use the same or similar methods, even while aware of the imperfection of those methods and disagreeing with each other about exactly why the methods are imperfect. Some methods can be used by different researchers in a way that yields similar enough results to create intellectual common ground.
  • Instruments — Researchers can use the same instruments and compare and discuss results even while disagreeing about how the instruments work or what the instruments are measuring. Some instruments will yield similar and interesting enough results to enable researcher discussion, communication, etc.
  • Theories — Researchers can discuss or act on the basis of a theory, even while all believing the theory is ultimately mistaken and while disagreeing with each other about how. Some theories will enable sufficiently fruitful discussion or yield sufficiently similar results when acted on to generate intellectual common ground.




Philosopher, research program designer.

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

How do you Create a Boson?

Quantum Jumps never happen.

READ/DOWNLOAD( Solar Energy: The physics and engin

Index: Birds, Birding, Nature

Male Rose-breasted Grosbeak, migrating, southern Louisiana, April 2021

scite and Informatics Group Partner to Bring the Next Generation of Citations to India

What This Drawing Taught Me About Four-Dimensional Spacetime

What’s next for the March for Science

The Modern Mind May Be 100,000 Years Old

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Geoff Anders

Geoff Anders

Philosopher, research program designer.

More from Medium

It’s Not What You Said, It’s How You Said It.

Santa Claus is Coming (Back) to Town

Laughter, Tears and Bad Music

A brief history of cannibalism